> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://sunnydeveloper.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# What do YOU mean by open source AI?
- URL: https://sunnydeveloper.com/what-do-you-mean-by-open-source-ai/
- Published: 2025-09-15T19:53:00.000Z
- Updated: 2025-09-15T20:27:22.000Z
- Author: Emma Irwin

*How OSPOs can drive alignment around meaning for openness and AI*

Ana Jiménez Santamaría’s blog post [*How Open Source Program Offices Make OSS and AI Work*](https://todogroup.org/blog/oss-and-ai-ospo-role/?ref=sunnydeveloper.com) did a great job of speaking to to the ways in which OSPOs can help organizations navigate AI risks. I also believe OSPOs also have a critical role to play in challenging their organizations to get the story straight on what they mean by “open source AI". 

### I don't think that means what you think it means...

This is not to enter the debate around "[what IS open source AI](https://thenewstack.io/the-case-against-osis-open-source-ai-definition/?ref=sunnydeveloper.com)", but instead to highlight lack of ecosystem clarity in answering this question: ***what does your organization actually MEAN when they say open source AI?*** What can your users and contributors **trust** to be true when they use and contribute to your products and projects?

Here are just a few ways open source AI terminology is being used - sometimes at odds with each other.

- **Government framing:** “We need to ensure America has leading open models founded on American values.” ([White House](https://www.nextgov.com/artificial-intelligence/2025/07/white-house-unveils-ai-action-plan-targeting-regulation-and-ideological-bias/406929/?ref=sunnydeveloper.com) AI action plan)
- **Industry marketing:** “Llama 3.1… the first frontier-level open source AI model.” ([Meta](https://ai.meta.com/blog/meta-llama-3-1/?ref=sunnydeveloper.com) Llama, which has a mixed license - announcement)
- **Foundation proposals:** “Models purported as ‘open source’ frequently employ bespoke licenses with ambiguous terms.” [(Linux Foundation, Model Openness Framework](https://lfaidata.foundation/blog/2024/04/17/introducing-the-model-openness-framework-promoting-completeness-and-openness-for-reproducibility-transparency-and-usability-in-ai/?ref=sunnydeveloper.com))
- **Free Software vision:** “Free ML requires software, raw training data, and scripts to grant users the four freedoms.” ([FSF is working on a freedom and machine learning definition](https://www.fsf.org/news/fsf-is-working-on-freedom-in-machine-learning-applications?ref=sunnydeveloper.com))
- **Policy application:** “The EU AI Act does not include a definition of ‘open source.’” ([Assessment of EU AI act on open source](https://www.orrick.com/en/Insights/2024/09/The-EU-AI-Act-Application-to-Open-Source-Projects?ref=sunnydeveloper.com))
- **Weights:** “The product must include the weights and allow distribution of the weights…” ([Open Weights definition](https://opensource.org/ai/open-weights?ref=sunnydeveloper.com))
- **Public AI:** “A vision for a robust ecosystem of initiatives that promote public goods, public orientation, and public use throughout every step of AI development and deployment.” ([Mozilla on Public AI](https://assets.mofoprod.net/network/documents/Public%5FAI%5FMozilla.pdf?ref=sunnydeveloper.com))
- **Coding Assistant Confusion**: "*Llama 2, Mistral, Mixtral, Mistral-7B, Falcon, GPT-NeoX, GPT-J, Stable Diffusion, Whisper, BLOOM, T5, BERT, DistilBERT*" GitHub Copilot with Claude 4 proving me with a list of open source AI (which are not all the same).

### Opportunity leadership and creativity in OSPOs

This is both a creative opportunity for ecosystem leadership, and I would say, a key responsibility for OSPOs right now - to help their organizations stand out by declaring that they are trustworthy, and open in the ways that matter to users. 

- **Clarify position**: define what YOU mean by “open source AI” and variations that may be true in certain use-cases. Maybe data cannot be open, be clear on the criteria that influences such a decision (safety, privacy etc).
- **Educate internally**: In the race to 'win' don't take on **cultural** debt, teach employees about open beyond licensing. Align and build culture that reflects a commitment in community - as we have for open source for years.
- **Innovate user documentation**: experiment with new ways of detailing 'openness' in a product or project that summarize 'complexity of ingredients' in simple ways anyone can understand, trust or challenge (cereal label for inspiration below).
- **Build trust**: In the race to 'win', don't take on **reputational** debt, create processes and practices that developers and users can publicly verify. Get feedback from engineering teams, and users alike - and act on it. Update your open source @ company name website with all of this nice alignment - other organizations will follow.

![AI MODEL TRANSPARENCY FACTS Pythia 12B (EleutherAI) Core Components Model Weights ✓ Available Model Architecture ✓ Available Inference Code ✓ Available Training Code ✓ Available Raw Training Data ✓ The Pile (825GB) Data Processing ✓ Full Pipeline Intermediate Checkpoints ✓ 143 Checkpoints Training Logs ✓ Complete Logs Evaluation Suite ✓ Full Harness Apache 2.0 ✨ WHAT THIS ENABLES: • Full model reproduction from scratch • Custom data preprocessing • Training continuation from any checkpoint • Complete training analysis & debugging • Custom evaluation protocols Framework Compliance OSI OSAID 1.0 ✓ PASS FSF Free ML ✓ PASS MOF Classification Class I (Open Science) EU AI Act ✓ Exemption Qualified DATA TRANSPARENCY GOLD STANDARD • 22 constituent datasets documented • Complete data provenance trail • Deduplication process detailed](https://storage.ghost.io/c/dd/54/dd541b9a-0a36-4d3d-9642-9285522c2776/content/images/2025/09/image-22.png)

Claude's attempt at cereal labels for OSS AI

No one has the full picture yet, but that's precisely why OSPOs matter: they can connect dots, create organizational clarity, and provide leadership in a space where trust is currently scarce. 

**NOTE**: If at any point, you've read this and though "Emma doesn't know x about this particular thing", you are probably right and that's kind of the point here. Its very hard to gather the big picture.

---

*Available for* [*consulting sessions,*](https://calendly.com/emma-irwin-z6wm/30min?ref=sunnydeveloper.com) *or*[ *sponsor me on GitHub*](https://github.com/sponsors/emmairwin?ref=sunnydeveloper.com) *to support writing like this.*